[catatoniaone]

Originally Posted by Lewymocha06

no they were not fired! They all left of their own accord! God you are just so annoying sometimes! Always jumping to conclusions!

Jess left because him and avril used to date.
Charlie left Cause he had his own life to get on with.
Evan left cause he got a record deal.
Matt left in between the space of UMS and TBDT(to get on with his career)

This is why they left.

Not because they were fired or because Avril was afraid to disobey her ecord company(Which she was never afraid to do e.g. being that she broke away and wrote TBDT without their supervision)

So Yeah.

DUDE please read Avril interviews before you " JUMP to CONCLUTIONS ! "
WE only make asumptions based on Information from Different places is`s not jumping to a conclution to read a interview were Avril was asked how she told her band they were fired and you were not even in this forum when some one from here talked to Matt last year so please dont be annoying .

What was wrong with your old band?
"I wanted a bigger band with more experience. Were with eight now. I hired a keyboardplayer and two dancers.
Theyve been in bigger bands and been on tour for a long time. Theyre great musicians. I was ready for them.
I kept one bandmember though. You know, before this everything was ok. I sang live and I was good at it,
but the show had to go to a new level."

So you had to fire people...
"Yes, thats how it goes. I am not a band, Im a soloartist and then its usual to play with new musicians."

Did you fire them, or did you let someone fire them?
"No i told them myself i wanted another band. Not everyone was too happy with that."

And the new bandmembers are hired by yourself?
"Im the sort of girl who exactly knows what she wants. And thats a good thing with my work. I always have to make
a lot of decissions. I decided everything myself in my whole career and meddle with everything."

This was translated by someone from Bandaids from a magazine article posted in the MEDIA forum . there is also other articles were she was asked how she told them and she said she told them over the phone.
Avril was asked again outright a few weeks later about her decision to get a new band and how she went about it and about her relationship with her friends now and she flatly refused to answer.
that and the other things give us our conclusion .
If it was any different then why didnt she say so when asked ??
Why does she never talk too or hang out with any of her old band ??

(Which she was never afraid to do e.g. being that she broke away and wrote TBDT without their supervision)

Is it intresting that she also flatly refused to answer questions about making TBDT when she was directly asked about working with Max Martin and Kara dioguardi like how they came to work with each other .
now this is just a guess but could it be that Avril doesnt answer questions because if she did then the whole " I made the album all on my own without the lable or even management knowing anything or having any involvement , and I am not going to work with any of the GO TO songwriters and producers that the label want me to work with " might look like bullshit and more marketing than reality . a bit like the whole band as "best friends and family "but hay thats just a guess.
of course Avril could just answer direct questions fully and honestly but she has chosen not too for what ever reason ^^ so we Guess and make conclusions based on all the information we have.
and its not just me that comes to the same opinion.