*nods* the new book is awesome!! A lot of the unexected
Mollywobbles! PMSL classic
I dunno which is my fave movie wise ... they're all slightly different (directing etc). I'm not sure the thriller theme was necessarily the right way to approach this movie, he should have incorportated some other things as well ... the book itself isn't a thriller really
I guess number 3 is my fave - most acurate to the feel of the book even tho some cool bits were missed out, it still made sense. The new one missed some cool bits out (which was expected due to the size of it) some parts just didn't flow or make sense if you hadn't read the books.