What do you think?
I think it's better and wish Avril could do more catchy ballads like that...
Better than the whole album? No, but it's still a really good song.
Lord, no! lol It's a perfect song but not better than the whole album! To me it had a Goodbye Lullaby feel to it.
HELL NO! The song is mediocre. My Happy Ending and I'm With You are far better ballads. Those ballads are probably better than most of Goodbye Lullaby, not WLYG.
I wouldn't say it out did a whole album, but it would definitely fit on GL! It definitely would have added something to it.
FITS with Goodbye Lullaby, but it's not better than the album, It's a beautiful song
Who Knows, What Could Happen? Do What You Do Just Keep On Laughin'!
Who Knows? Good Song, Just Live Your Life!
Banner By Me
How can you compare a meager song that didn't even make the cut for a previous album with a whole album?
I'm glad she didn't do anything like "Won't let you go" on "GL" 'cause it's really "cliché" and boring as hell. She could give that song to any pop artist, nobody would see a big difference (assuming that someone would actually be interested in releasing that song someday). The Lyrics may be less repetitive compared to the songs on "GL" but the music is really crappy. That's not the kind of ballads that I'd like to listen to in 2011... It's so outdated.
Holy NO!!! Actually, I already get tired of the ballad of WLYG. I mean,it's a beautiful song too,but if you want me to keep repeat of hearing it,sorry I can't. This song can't compare to GL album. If you want me to pick one song from GL and compare with WLYG,I'd say only "Goodbye" can compare with WLYG, which only these songs will make me do the thing I seldom do,TO skip the song,Lol!
This song sounds nothing like anything from GL, it doesn't sound like it's exactly from any era, just really similar to KHO (Which I don't consider part of TBDT era because it got released way earlier than the album.).
I don't think you can really compare a song to an album though. If you're really going to though, WLYG isn't better than GL. GL isn't amazing though....
You just have something against GL. WLYG is a good song, but it's nowhere near as good as the whole album. You like WLYG because it's a catchy, cliche ballad. I've seen your posts before.
WLYG is absolutely a good song. but there are a lot of tracks n GL that are comparably good. WLYG isn't better, but if it on it, GL would be better.
i'm starting to think WLYG is overrated!
In my opinion Everybody Hurts, 4 Real & Darlin are better, so no